Detachable vs Fixed Carry Handle For AR-15: Weighing Your Choices

Hey there, gun enthusiasts! Let's chat about one of the coolest parts of an AR-15: the carry handle. Whether you're a seasoned shooter or just getting into the game, this guide's got you covered. We'll break down the differences between Fixed carry handles and Detachable carry handles, so you can figure out which one's right for you.

Fixed Carry Handles: Old School Cool, 

Fixed carry handles are like the classic rock of the AR-15 world. They're built right into the upper receiver and ain't going anywhere. Here's the lowdown:

Pros:

• Tough as nails: These bad boys can take a beating and keep on ticking.
• Simple and cheap: No need to buy extra stuff or fiddle around with attachments.
• Classic look: If you're into that retro military vibe, this is your jam.

Cons:

• Not much wiggle room for customization: You're kinda stuck with what you've got.
• Extra weight: It's always there, whether you want it or not.

on the other hand, provide versatility, allowing for the attachment and removal of various sighting systems as needed. Users often prefer them due to their:

• Replaceability
• Upgradability
• Enhanced customization

Detachable Carry Handles: Mix and Match

Detachable carry handles are like the Swiss Army knives of the AR-15 world. You can slap 'em on or take 'em off whenever you feel like it. Here's the scoop:

Pros:

• Versatile as heck: Want to switch up your sights? No problem!
• Easy to use: Most of 'em snap on and off without any tools.
• Adjustable: Some fancy models let you tweak 'em for different shooting scenarios.

Cons:

• Not always great for actually carrying: Some might be a bit wobbly or uncomfortable.
• Kinda old news: Some folks think they're outdated compared to newer sighting systems.
• Gotta watch out for compatibility: Not all handles play nice with all rifles.

It's wise to note that not all detachable carry handles are created equal. Commercial-spec options might be of lesser quality compared to military-spec products.

History of AR-15 Carry Handles: A Journey Through Time

The history of AR-15 carry handles is an intriguing one, taking us back to the M-16A1 rifle, where the carry handle was most commonly found. This fixed carry handle also appeared on other famous models like the XM-177.

The A1 Carry Handle: The Original

The original carry handle, known as the A1 carry handle, featured:

• A windage-adjustable rear sight
• Front sight elevation adjustments
• An L-shaped sight aperture with two different aperture options

As the design evolved, newer models like the M-16A2 and M-16A4 introduced improvements to the rear sight, offering both windage and elevation adjustments for better accuracy and versatility.

From Fixed to Detachable Carry Handles

Fixed carry handles generally provided users with a reliable built-in sight, while detachable carry handles added the versatility of choosing different sight options for shooters. With the rise of flat-top rifles as the new standard, detachable rail-mount carry handles emerged for those who still preferred their sights mounted high.

In this section, we'll explore the detachable carry handle option for AR-15 rifles, which allows users to attach and remove the carry handle as needed.

Pros: Versatility, Adaptability, and Ease of Attachment

• Versatility: Detachable carry handles enable users to easily switch between configurations based on their needs or preferences. For example, they can be removed to accommodate other sighting systems or accessories.
• Adaptability: Colt's detachable carry handle, used by the military, can be adjusted to fit various shooting scenarios, such as different distances and target sizes.
• Ease of attachment: Most detachable carry handles can be effortlessly attached and removed from the rifle without any tools, making them highly convenient. The mil-spec Picatinny rail allows for an easy and secure connection.

Cons: Carrying Issues, Obsolescence, and Compatibility

• Not ideal for carrying: Some detachable carry handles may not be suitable for actually carrying the rifle, as they might lack sturdiness or be difficult to grip comfortably.
• Obsolete: It has been argued that detachable carry handles have fallen out of general use, with many gun enthusiasts and military forces opting for alternative methods like sling systems.
• Compatibility: Not all AR-15 models may be compatible with all types of detachable carry handles, so it's essential to check compatibility before making a purchase.

Making the Call: Which One's For You?

Alright, so how do you choose? Here's what to think about:

1. What's your style? If you're all about that classic look, go fixed. If you like to switch things up, detachable might be your best bet.
2. What are you using it for? Just plinking at the range? Fixed could work. Want to do some tactical stuff or compete? Detachable gives you more options.
3. How much do you wanna spend? Fixed handles are usually cheaper since they're built-in.
4. How strong do you need it? Fixed handles can take more abuse, but detachable ones are easier to replace if they break.

Popular Picks

Fixed Carry Handle Models:

• Colt: The OG of AR-15s, known for quality.
• ArmaLite: They've got some sweet A2 and A4 models.
• Bushmaster: Check out their XM15-E2S series for that classic look.

Detachable Carry Handle Models:

• Colt: Yep, they do detachable too. Versatile!
• Smith & Wesson: Their M&P15 series is pretty slick.
• Palmetto State Armory: Good variety of options here.
• OZARK ARMAMENT: Hey, that's us! We've got a solid, budget-friendly option if you're looking to save some cash.

The Bottom Line

At the end of the day, whether you go fixed or detachable comes down to what you want out of your AR-15. Fixed handles are great if you're into that classic look and don't mind the extra weight. Detachable handles are perfect if you like to mix things up and want more flexibility.
Remember, there's no wrong choice here. It's all about what works best for you and your shooting style. So go ahead, pick your poison, and have a blast (pun totally intended) with your AR-15!
Got questions? Hit us up at support@ozarkarmament.com. We're always happy to chat about all things AR-15!

Quick FAQs

Article Written By Matt Rice, Owner Operator of OZARK ARMAMENT 

Matt Rice is the founder and owner operator of OZARK ARMAMENT. He started the company in 2016 with a vision to bring quality, affordable firearm accessories to every person who wants to improve their shooting experience. With his dedication to providing old-school customer service and his attention to detail in the development and manufacturing of gear, Matt has helped OZARK ARMAMENT become a respected name in the firearm accessories industry.